« Death Penalty for Drug Dealing | Main | Church Corruption in Practice and Doctrine; Protecting Homosexual Priests »
February 21, 2005
Hoppe Academic Freedom Case: University Surrenders
The President seems to have reversed the university's punishment of Professor Hans Hoppe, the economist who lost a year's pay for saying in class that homosexuals have higher time preference (see my page of links here). . . .
"I have reviewed the report of the Executive Vice President and Provost
regarding the discrimination complaint filed by a student against Dr. Hoppe.
Professor Hoppe is represented by the ACLU and counsel. I have written to his
counsel today regarding my review.
Professor Hoppe has consistently held the opinion that his classroom materials
consist of scholarly and relevant theories that have support in the academic
economics community. I believe professors are entitled the freedom to teach
theories and to espouse opinions that are out of the mainstream or are
controversial.
It is my understanding that Professor Hoppe does not assert that materials he
presents are the opinions of UNLV, nor has he ever purported to speak for UNLV.
Whether anyone in the University agrees or disagrees with Professor Hoppe’s
theories or his opinions is not ultimately relevant. . . ."
This matter has finally reached the level of presidential appeal, and I have
completed my review. As a result, I have directed that the
letter of instruction and related materials be withdrawn from Professor Hoppe’s
personnel file and that no further action on this complaint be taken by the
University. Attached below is a statement which further
details my rationale for this decision.. . .
I found the letter above because
EconomicsDaily.com has a February 15 page of links.
The Feb 19 Review Journal reports on this, and says
Attorney Al Marquis said the sabbatical is appropriate compensation for the year
of persecution Hoppe suffered at the hands of UNLV administrators. "He just
wants the time to pursue his research," Marquis said. . . .
Marquis praised interim Chancellor Jim Rogers, who met with Harter on Thursday,
for negotiating the removal of the letter and supporting freedom of speech. He
said he plans to meet with Rogers, system Chief Counsel Dan Klaich and hopefully
Harter on Tuesday to discuss the matter further.
"We're trying to resolve the matter without the need of going to court," Marquis
said.
But Hoppe and his attorneys weren't satisfied with the proposed resolution.
They said they also want an apology and a year-long sabbatical for the
professor.
Hoppe seems to be a good bargainer-- when the other side makes a concession,
press for more. I doubt he'll get it, though. It will be interesting
to see if he suffers unofficial punishment. If you recall from
my first post on this,
the official punishment was going to be a year without a salary increase.
It would be pretty easy to retain that punishment, even after removing the
official letter from his file. At some point, maybe I'll blog on my own history
of salary increase-- substantial every year for ten years till the year of my
weblog controversy, when it fell, without comment, to 1%.
Posted by erasmuse at February 21, 2005 02:09 PM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.rasmusen.org/mt-new/mt-tb.cgi/445
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Hoppe Academic Freedom Case: University Surrenders:
» hoppe hoopla from South(west)paw
I have been so busy with dismalpresident@harvard and profbirdbrain@ucla that I am late to the gate on the hoopla about Hans Hoppe, a rightwing economist at University of Nevada who is under fire for saying that homosexuals �discount the future�... [Read More]
Tracked on February 27, 2005 01:28 PM